Signed open letter to the Harvard community that claims Hamas’ October 7 attack had “no military or other specific objective” and“meets the definition of a war crime.” It claims the IOF was “engaging in self-defense” but makes no mention of Israel’s many unprovoked attacks on Gaza over the past decades. It calls Hamas “terrorists” and says Harvard students who signed a letter holding the Israeli government responsible are “condoning the mass murder of civilians based only on their nationality.“ The letter expresses concern for the safety of Jewish and Israeli students but no concern for Muslim or Palestinian students.

The student letter in question contains zero anti-semitic language; it criticizes the state of Israel (not Jewish people) and the subjugation of Palestinians under apartheid, forced displacement, and ethnic cleansing.