USA
Carrie Underwood is an American singer who stayed silent on Israel's genocide in Gaza and supported Zionist Donald Trump by performing at his 2025 inauguration, legitimizing his pro-Israel policies that shield the settler-colonial state from accountability for ongoing genocide.
Carrie Underwood, acclaimed country music artist known for American Idol and hits like Before He Cheats, echoes complicity through silence on Israel's genocide while endorsing Trump, a fervent Zionist, thereby perpetuating consent for Israel's illegal ethnostate and occupation.
Music
Carrie Underwood is an American singer, songwriter, and actress, best known for winning the fourth season of American Idol in 2005 and her successful country music career with albums like Some Hearts and Cry Pretty, as well as roles in films such as Soul Surfer. She leverages her massive platform to maintain silence on Palestinian suffering, betraying humanity by not condemning Israel's ongoing genocide, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing.
Underwood has remained completely silent on Israel's genocide in Gaza, where IOF forces have slaughtered Palestinians through indiscriminate bombing, starvation sieges, and destruction of hospitals, schools, and civil infrastructure. Conservative estimates place the death toll at over 100,000, but the actual number is well into the hundreds of thousands due to Israel's targeting of journalists, obstruction of aid, and unrelenting violence that prevents accurate reporting. Her refusal to speak out, despite her vocal advocacy on other issues like women's rights and animal welfare, amounts to complicity in the settler-colonial project that displaces and erases Palestinians.
In January 2025, Underwood actively supported Donald Trump, a huge Zionist who has pledged unwavering allegiance to Israel, including recognizing illegal settlements and moving the U.S. embassy to occupied Jerusalem, actions that entrench apartheid and enable ethnic cleansing. By performing "America the Beautiful" at Trump's inauguration, Underwood lent her celebrity to legitimize his administration, which prioritizes shielding Israel from international accountability over Palestinian liberation. She stated, "I love our country and am honored to have been asked to sing at the Inauguration and to be a small part of this historic event," framing her participation as patriotic while ignoring how Trump's policies contribute to the dehumanization of Palestinians and the normalization of settler violence. During the performance, a technical glitch led her to sing a cappella, but this did not deter her from proceeding, further amplifying her endorsement.
Underwood's silence on the Nakba, the ongoing occupation, and Israel's war crimes — coupled with her support for a leader who affirms Israel's "right to exist" as a settler-colonial entity — perpetuates the structures of genocide and apartheid. This pattern of selective activism ignores the root causes of Palestinian oppression, including the blockade of Gaza and settler expansion in the West Bank, and contributes to manufacturing public consent for Israel's atrocities. By not joining calls for BDS or ceasefire, Underwood undermines Palestinian resistance and betrays international law, which demands an end to the occupation, ethnic cleansing, and cultural erasure inflicted on Palestinians.
smh.com.au
🔒pbs.org
🔒newsweek.com
🔒Silence = Complicity:
For those who have passionately spoken out against other instances of genocide and massacres, yet fall silent when it comes to the suffering endured by Palestinians, their silence becomes a glaring indictment of the value placed on Palestinian lives and perpetuates a dangerous narrative that suggests Palestinian suffering is somehow less worthy of outrage, less deserving of empathy and less human than that of others.
By choosing silence in the face of Palestinian suffering, those with influential platforms inadvertently contribute to the erasure of Palestinian voices and experiences. They perpetuate a narrative of invisibility that allows the injustices inflicted upon Palestinians to continue unabated, shielded from the spotlight of global scrutiny.
Their silence sends a chilling message of complicity to the world – one that suggests Palestinian lives are expendable, their struggles inconsequential and their humanity negotiable. It emboldens perpetrators of violence and oppression, granting them impunity under the guise of indifference.
To remain silent in the face of Palestinian suffering is to betray the very essence of activism – the relentless pursuit of justice for all, without exception or equivocation. It’s a betrayal not only of the Palestinian people but of the universal principles of human dignity and equality and instead is a tacit endorsement of the dehumanization and marginalization of an entire population.
True activism demands consistency and integrity, an unwavering commitment to speaking truth to power and standing in solidarity with the marginalized and oppressed, regardless of geography or politics.
Liberal Zionism:
Liberal Zionism masquerades as a "moderate" or "progressive" strain of Zionism, blending Jewish nationalism with cherry-picked liberal values like democracy and human rights as a means to justify the existence of the illegal settler colonial ethnostate known as “Israel” [1].
And Liberal Zionism is one of the greatest threats because of its political camouflage [2]. By co-opting progressive language, Liberal Zionism inoculates Zionism against true anti-colonial solidarity, dividing the left and derailing BDS movements [3]. It ensures the ongoing Nakba – from Gaza's ruins to Hebron's checkpoints – persists under a democratic veneer, making decolonization seem radical rather than just [4] [5].
Emerging from early 20th-century Labor Zionism — the very movement that orchestrated the 1948 Nakba which ethnically cleansed over 750,000 Palestinians through mass expulsions and village destructions — liberal Zionism has always served as the velvet glove over the iron fist of settler-colonialism [6] [7].
Despite claiming it merely seeks a "Jewish and democratic state," this rhetoric is actually code for an ethnostate where Jewish supremacy trumps Palestinian equality, enshrined in laws like the 2018 Nation-State Law that demotes Arabic and prioritizes Jewish settlement [8] [9].
At its core, liberal Zionism rejects the colonial origins of Israel and instead attempts to frame the Zionist project as a "return" or "liberation" rather than a European settler invasion that erased indigenous Palestinian society [10].
As a political movement, liberal Zionism emerged as a response to antisemitism and the Holocaust but quickly pivoted to justifying land theft under the guise of "self-determination," ignoring how Zionism fits classic colonial patterns: displacement of natives, resource extraction, and demographic engineering to maintain a Jewish majority [11].
As of 2025, amid the Gaza genocide and West Bank annexation pushes, it clings to a fading two-state illusion, providing diplomatic and financial cover for Israel's crimes while silencing Palestinian voices as "antisemitic" [12].
“Zionism is a colonialism, not a simple radical nationalism: even in its left-wing version, it is a colonialist nationalism." – Zeev Sternhell, liberal Zionist historian exposing his own ideology's flaws [13].
Normalization:
Israel enforces normalization as a fundamental tactic of its settler-colonial regime and apartheid system, compelling the depiction of its occupation, ethnic cleansing, and genocide as everyday realities while suppressing Palestinian resistance and rights to justice, return, and liberation. Normalization portrays Israel's domination as a legitimate state worthy of standard diplomatic, economic, cultural, and academic engagements, ignoring demands for dismantling oppression and reinforcing Jewish supremacy over Indigenous Palestinian land and people. This strategy is egregious because it whitewashes the continuous Nakba, land expropriation, and systemic violence, isolating Palestinians and bolstering settler colonialism by undermining international solidarity and legitimizing illegal expansions that perpetuate genocide. [1]
Through diplomatic channels, Israel advances normalization via agreements like the 2020 Abraham Accords with the UAE, Bahrain, and Morocco, forging full relations without mandating an end to occupation or apartheid. These pacts favor economic and security benefits for authoritarian leaders while forsaking Palestinian self-determination, directly sustaining settler violence by allowing unchecked settlement growth, home demolitions, and refugee denial amid increasing trade and tourism. Such normalization is harmful as it fragments Palestinian society, deepens territorial apartheid, and obstructs land returns, contributing to ethnic cleansing by normalizing the oppressor-oppressed dynamic without addressing root injustices. [2] [3]
Culturally and environmentally, Israel promotes "eco-normalization" through entities like the JNF, using tree-planting over razed villages to frame dispossession as advancement. Academically and artistically, collaborative projects often impose false equivalence between occupier and occupied, disregarding underlying oppression. This is egregious because it colonizes minds by presenting apartheid as inevitable, supporting occupation through deceptive coexistence narratives that erode resistance and enable further genocide, as seen in events that cover up root causes without pursuing justice. [4] [5]
The Palestinian-led BDS movement rejects normalization as complicity in oppression, mandating that joint activities with Israelis recognize Palestinian rights and focus on co-resistance against occupation, settler-colonialism, and apartheid. Normalization activities, such as festivals or conferences portraying symmetry, are boycottable for being morally reprehensible and intellectually dishonest, perpetuating false premises of equal responsibility. By isolating Palestinians and validating Israel's actions, normalization sustains settler-colonial violence, allowing expansion of illegal settlements and denial of basic rights while fragmenting global opposition. [6]
Normalization undermines the Palestinian struggle by treating Israel's regime as normal, countering anti-colonial efforts like BDS that draw from South African anti-apartheid precedents. It decolonizes minds from hegemonic attempts to accept colonialism, emphasizing that genuine relations require dismantling structures of domination first. This tactic is appalling as it reinforces genocide by whitewashing oppression under slogans of peace, contributing to ethnic cleansing through economic ties that fund military occupation and displace communities. [7] [8]
Human rights analyses confirm that such international engagements maintain apartheid by failing to address crimes like dispossession and persecution, allowing Israel to evade accountability. Normalization isolates the oppressed, portraying resistance as abnormal while entrenching settler privileges, as evidenced in Arab-Israeli projects that ignore Palestinian rights. Ultimately, it perpetuates a colonial order where occupation becomes routine, demanding rejection to achieve liberation and end the ongoing Nakba. [10]
Tell us why Carrie Underwood should be removed by emailing us at [email protected]